Diocese refuses to say why it gave award to pro-LGBTQUEER+ Catholic grad

Featured Image

Diocese refuses to say why it gave award to pro-LGBTQUEER+ Catholic grad

HAMILTON, Ontario, August 7, 2018 (LifeSiteNews) — An Ontario Catholic diocese won’t say why it gave an award for exemplary Catholic leadership to a Catholic university graduate with a Twitter account that abounds with pro-LGBTQIA+ sentiments.

“A decision by the diocese has been made not to participate in the story, not to issue any comment on this,” Hamilton diocesan communication director Pam Aleman told LifeSiteNews.

The Diocese of Hamilton student awards recognize academic excellence and conduct that “exemplifies Catholic leadership qualities, Christian values, and a commitment to service in the community.”

This year’s choice for St. Jerome’s University (SJU), the Catholic college at the University of Waterloo, is Lydia Notten, a graduate of its sexuality, marriage and family studies program.

Notten, who received the award from chancellor Msgr. Murray Kroetsch, is described on the diocesan website as having “fostered a community and culture of equality and human dignity for all.”

But her public Twitter account, as documented below, is devoid of any reference to Catholicism while uncritically promoting the LGBTQIA+ life.

(Perhaps that’s no surprise given that SJU’s sexuality, marriage and family studies department invited transgender activist Sason Bear Bergman to speak at its 2015 symposium. A biological woman who identifies as a trans “man,” and married to J Wallace Skelton, equity adviser for the Toronto District School Board, Bergman infamously wrote in the Huffington Post her goal was “indoctrinate your children into my LGBTQ agenda (And I’m not a bit sorry).”)

Aleman told LifeSiteNews the diocesan student awards, also given to graduates of each Catholic high school, are awarded “on behalf of the diocese, but schools — high schools, universities — they choose who they give this award to.”

St. Jerome’s University (SJU) refused to comment on how it selects its choice for the diocesan award.

“We do not discuss these matters and will not be making comments on our students or graduates,” communications officer Allannah Cormier told LifeSiteNews in an email.

Award winner’s mom pro-LGBT director of education

Notten is the daughter of Loretta Notten, director of education for Waterloo Catholic District School Board (WCDSB).

Notten’s mother tweeted her “solidarity with LGBQT” with an image of a rainbow-coloured heart to show empathy for those affected by the tragedy after the June 2016 Orlando gay-night club massacre.

More significantly, Notten sent an email urging students and staff to wear purple shirts and fly school flags at half-mast to “stand up to homophobia and all hate crimes” and be in “solidarity with all LGBTQ persons.”

American writer Joseph Sciambra, who left the homosexual life and returned his Catholic faith 18 years ago, faulted WCDSB for its politically loaded response to the horrific shooting.

“I think it is wonderful and noble for any Catholic to pray for those who died so needlessly in the Orlando massacre, but a Catholic can do this without adopting the vocabulary or the symbols of the modern ‘gay rights’ movement,” he told LifeSiteNews at that time.

Director Notten’s tweet showed she’s either “naive or she has an agenda,” added Sciambra.

“As a Catholic educator, she should have known better,” he said, pointing out that terms such as “gay,” “lesbian,” or “LGBTQ” reduce persons created in the image and likeness of God to no more the sum of their drives and attractions.

Notten’s other daughter, Julianna Notten, is a self-described “queer woman” and  filmmaker, whose film “Erin’s guide to kissing girls,” features a 12-year-old lesbian protagonist.

Director’s predecessor bishops’ pro-sex-ed secretary

Problematic tweets from Waterloo-area Catholics aren’t new.

Indeed, they’ve come from the bishops’ general secretary Roger Lawler, who is also Loretta Notten’s predecessor as WCDSB director of education.

Lawler held the post for 15 years before being hired in September 2014 by the Assembly of Catholic Bishops of Ontario.

Under Lawler’s watch, the WCDSB approved a number of controversial materials for school use and adopted policies that critics said “created an air of tolerance towards active homosexuality,” and which LifeSiteNews documented in detail in 2015.

A partisan Liberal, Lawler tweeted support for former Kathleen Wynne’s controversial sex-ed in 2015, and in 2017 tweeted outrage with American President Trump for rescinding the Mexico City policy and thereby “cut(ting) off family planning for millions of poor women globally” and “reinstat(ing])Reagan-era abortion restrictions.”

ACBO president, London Archbishop Roger Fabbro, did not respond when LifeSiteNews brought these tweets to his attention. Lawler has since made his Twitter account private.

Problematic tweets from diocesan award winner As for Diocese of Hamilton award winner Lydia Notten, she was tweeting support of the LGBTQIA+ agenda as early as 2015:

Lydia Notten@LydiaNotten

Also sporting some purple to support the LGBTQ+ community & 💜 @UWglow

More recently, Notten tweeted frequent praise of Netflix reality show Queer Eye, in which five homosexual men give lifestyle and beauty advice to “straight” men.

“I am so here for the #Fab5 tearing down toxic masculinity one day at a time,” she tweeted June 20, two days after this:

Listen I know I have been tweeting a lot about @QueerEye lately but a) I firmly believe this show can change the world and b) I have yet to watch an episode where they don’t speak directly to my soul c) I need everyone to watch this show

Lydia Notten@LydiaNotten

Listen I know I have been tweeting a lot about @QueerEye lately but a) I firmly believe this show can change the world and b) I have yet to watch an episode where they don’t speak directly to my soul c) I need everyone to watch this show

Notten promoted the Queer Eye episode on trans “man” Skyler, retweeting this from Equality California, the “nation’s largest statewide#LGBTQ civil rights organization”: twitter.com/eqca/status/1008103194520686594

Equality California


YES! This is the representation we need. Thank you, @QueerEye 👏👏

“For us to have a culturally relevant conversation about the trans experience is something that two years ago I don’t think you would have seen on television” – @KaramoBrown www.digitalspy.com/tv/queer-eye/feature/a859406/queer-eye-skyler-trans-season-2-episode-5-netflix/ …“

Queer Eye just gave us its most important episode yet

The Fab Five hope it will bring about real change.


Lydia Notten@LydiaNotten

hi I’m going to need everyone I know to watch season 2 episode 5 of @QueerEye and report back once you have pls & thank u

Lydia Notten@LydiaNotten

Genuinely though @tanfrance @KaramoBrown @bobbyberk @antoni @jvn @transginger… THANK YOU for this episode, thank you for these conversations, thank you for this honesty. This show and this episode are so important, and I’m glad content like this is going out into today’s world.

Notable retweets by Notten include this observation in March 2018 by self-identified queer poet “the one with the ☭ tatto”:

the one with the ☭ tattoo@void_daddy_

the future isnt female. the future is nonbinary it’s genderfluid it’s queer and it’s trans it’s natives rising up against their colonizers it’s sex workers getting coin it’s gay it’s bi it’s pan it’s ace it’s ppl of color it’s ppl w disabilities THE FUTURE IS INTERSECTIONAL

Notten informed followers in June that the “A” in LGBTQIA+ is for “Asexuality” after Melissa Fabello, self-described “body acceptance activist, sexuality scholar, and patriarchy smasher” blasted those who mistakenly assumed it stood for “Allies”:


Lydia Notten@LydiaNotten

The A is for Asexuality pass it on

Melissa A. Fabello, PhD



She urged followers on June 22 to sign a Lead Now petition objecting to newly elected Premier Doug Ford’s plan to repeal the sex-ed:

Paul McKone@pdmckone

Doug Ford plans to repeal Ontario’s consent-based Sex-Ed curriculum – in 2 weeks. Add your name to demand he doesn’t. http://you.leadnow.ca/petitions/doug-ford-keep-ontario-s-sex-ed-curriculum/  https://you.leadnow.ca/petitions/doug-ford-keep-ontario-s-sex-ed-curriculum?bucket=&source=twitter-share-button  via @leadnowca

Add your name: Doug Ford – don’t repeal the sex ed curriculum

The curriculum was designed by experts and parents. Youth deserve facts.


Notten opined the NDP was the best option:

Lydia Notten@LydiaNotten

Party Platforms to help get you educated!:
Andrea Horwath & the NDP: www.ontariondp.ca/platform 
Kathleen Wynne & the Liberals: https://platform.ontarioliberal.ca
Doug Ford & the PCs have not published their platform, but here is there website: www.ontariopc.ca

Lydia Notten@LydiaNotten

It’s also worth noting that the polls show there is very little chance of the Liberals coming back into power. If we want to prevent Ford Nation (and the Trump-like ideals Ford represents) from coming to Ontario, NDP is currently our best shot.https://newsinteractives.cbc.ca/onvotes/poll-tracker/ 

CBC News Ontario Poll Tracker

The CBC News Poll Tracker is your guide to following the polls in the 2018 Ontario provincial election.


Get AQ Email Updates

Leave a Reply