Carmelite SOS: “Cor orans is the death-knell of Carmelite monasticism”

Carmelite SOS: “Cor orans is the death-knell of Carmelite monasticism”


St. Teresa of Avila, pray for us in this hour of darkness.

I have been contacted by a community of Carmelites who have seen the document, and are desperate to try to warn the remaining faithful Carmels of the Teresian reform.

Today’s piece for the Remnant contains some of their remarks:

Today I received an email from a monastery of cloistered Carmelite nuns about the new document from the Vatican’s Congregation for Religious. They’re helping me examine this document, having kindly volunteered to serve as consultants, to help me understand it from an inside position. These, I might add, are not what we would consider a “traditionalist” community. They have only the Novus Ordo Mass and use the new rite Divine Office in their native vernacular language. For obvious reasons I can’t identify them, even to say what country they are in.

Writing to me in English, by way of introductory comments in their longer analysis of the document that will be forthcoming, Sister T, fully professed and a senior member of the monastery’s council, said, “The Cor Orans document is the death-knell of Carmel. It signals the end of the contemplative monastic life. Not only does it destroy the autonomy of the Monasteries, something Our Holy Mother St. Teresa was extremely insistent about, but it also removes the Superior, dissolves her authority and power, removes the financial independence of each Monastery, and destroys the specificity of each charism.

“This is a disaster. Especially for Carmel.”

Get AQ Email Updates

One comment on “Carmelite SOS: “Cor orans is the death-knell of Carmelite monasticism”

  1. Thank you, Tom, for this update. Hilary White is doing yeoman work bringing this to public attention. She is nearly alone in doing so, although a few Trad sites and more general outlets are slowly catching on… for the moment, anyway.
    Cor Orans is a masterstroke by the Left, a “federalization” (sic!) intent on crushing every contemplative Order worldwide.
    The nuns are defenseless, threatened with expulsions and loss of monastic property that can date back centuries. It is Henry VIII all over again, literally.
    Bluntly, the Trad “internet reaction”, so far, has been muted or predictably focused on “prophesies” some claim point to just such a catastrophe. That simply won’t do. Not. At. All.
    As Miss White wrote early on, what this papal administrative action intends to do is to destroy the spiritual “mitochondria” of the entire Church, period. Without heroic religious, She will collapse for want of Her supernatural defense structure.
    Although there are only tiny monastic enclosures left across the world, any serious Catholic blessed to have known Carmelite, Dominican, etc. religious is fully aware that one hour of their prayer, even by one of their novices, gains more spiritual and temporal relief for the Church than all the liberal/NO “gathering” nonsense on an entire continent over a dozen years. And that is exactly why liberals want them dead, to put it coldly.

Leave a Reply