An Oxford University freshman with a 12-year “Catholic” education: “The extent of my religious education: ‘Love God, draw a rainbow’”

An Oxford University freshman with a 12-year “Catholic” education: “The extent of my religious education: ‘Love God, draw a rainbow’”

Oakland Bishop Michael Barber: “Students should be able to articulate the answers to three questions when they leave your school: ‘Why do I believe in God?’ ‘Why do I believe in Jesus Christ?’ ‘Why do I believe in the Catholic Church?'”


The following is by Most Rev. Michael C. Barber, SJ, Bishop of Oakland, California:

As we begin the new school year, I’d like to recognize the principals and presidents of our Catholic elementary and secondary schools. Catholic educators have a unique role in one of the primary missions of the Church: To form missionary disciples. You will be a success if your students leave your school — and your classroom — being a friend and a disciple of Jesus Christ.

How do we do that?

There are many ways, but I’d like to emphasize two: 1. Teach the Catholic Faith with seriousness and intellectual rigor. 2. Provide opportunities for students to experience the love and friendship of Jesus.

I once read an Op-Ed piece in The Tablet, one of Britain’s leading Catholic journals, written by a young woman who had just completed 12 years of Catholic school education and was now a freshman at Oxford University. She was really upset that, although she had received an outstanding education in the secular subjects of science, math, history, languages, etc., her religious education was trite and absolutely boring.
She was angry because she could not answer the basic questions about Catholicism put to her by her well-educated classmates. As she wrote, “The extent of my religious education was ‘Love God, draw a rainbow.’”

We need to give our students credit for their intelligence in the religion class as well as science and the liberal arts. Our theology courses need content. Students need to be presented with the in-depth teachings of Jesus and the Church, and the reasons why we believe.

Students should be able to articulate the answers to three questions when they leave your school: “Why do I believe in God?” “Why do I believe in Jesus Christ?” “Why do I believe in the Catholic Church?”

If you as educators (and parents) have difficulty answering these questions yourselves, may I recommend a superb book: “Fundamentals of the Faith. Essays in Christian Apologetics,” by Peter Kreeft. I’ve given more copies of this book away than any other in my years as a priest. Kreeft teaches philosophy at Boston College, and the book is a summation of his responses to all the inquiries — and objections — college students bring up about the Catholic Faith.

The second area we need to emphasize is experience. To know about Jesus is one thing. To know Jesus is another.

I ask educators in our Catholic schools to use all the means our Catholic religion provides to lead students to Christ:

Reverent and prayerful Masses, and worthy reception of Holy Communion. Days of Recollection and Retreats. Guided examination of conscience and making a good confession. Stations of the Cross and Benediction in Lent. Processions in honor of Our Lady — especially for Our Lady of Guadalupe. Adoration of Christ in the Blessed Sacrament. Practicing the daily Examen, (using resources found in the Sacred Story Institute), and other forms of prayer. Practicing the corporal and spiritual works of mercy. Serving the poor and needy, the lonely and the elderly. Remind students that when they help in a soup kitchen or St. Vincent de Paul food pantry, they are feeding Christ in the person of the poor. And there are many more.

[Note: These were Bishop Barber’s remarks to a meeting of presidents and principals of Diocese of Oakland Catholic schools on Aug. 7.]

Full story at Catholic Voice Oakland.

Get AQ Email Updates

4 comments on “An Oxford University freshman with a 12-year “Catholic” education: “The extent of my religious education: ‘Love God, draw a rainbow’”

  1. A terrible shame! All properly educated Novusordoites should know butterflies and unicorns in addition to rainbows!

    In Xto,

  2. I have 16 years of Catholic education prior to Vatican II and would recommend as a source for your study. The so-called Catechism of the Catholic Church was prepared following Vatican II and incorporates many of the errors of Modernism and, IMO, is in conflict with the 2,000 yr old Magisterium. It was prepared by Christoph Cardinal Schönborn and again, IMO, no friend of Tradition. The following quote gives the details: “The Second Vatican Council (1962-1965) brought many changes to church life and to the approach to theology and catechesis. Following the Council, there was a great crisis in catechesis, which Blessed Pope John Paul II addressed in his Apostolic Exhortation Catechesi Tradendae (1979). Twenty years after the conclusion of the Council, Blessed John Paul II asked that a universal catechism be prepared incorporating the teachings of Vatican II within the living tradition of the church. This project was overseen largely by Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger (later Pope Benedict XVI) and Dominican Father Christoph von Schonborn, now Cardinal Archbishop of Vienna).” –

    By the way, I do not agree with the analysis given on that site but as the saying goes: “It is what it is.” Nor do I claim any authority to teach others the Faith except that provided to me by my Confirmation in the Faith prior to Vatican II.

    • phaley says:

      I … would recommend [i.e., the original 1885 Baltimore Catechism (see the Wikipedia article on the Baltimore Catechism)]

      I also recommend that and some other catechisms:

      The 1941 Baltimore Catechism revised under the editorship of Fr. Francis O’Connell, the renowned moral theology professor at Catholic University of America, volume 4, Explanation of the Baltimore Catechism

      The Catechism of the Council of Trent, or Roman Catechism, or Catechism of St. Pius V, translated and edited by the Dominican Frs. John McHugh and Charles Callan – especially for its references to St. Thomas Aquinas’ Summa Theologica. It is available online at sites such as and reprinted by TAN Books, thus bringing together two great books the Council of Trent praised (the Summa) and authorized (the Catechism) as well as recommended by many later Popes.

      Speaking of a catechism named in honor of a sainted Pope Pius: The Catechism of St. Pius X, also available online and in book-form.

  3. Just to be clear – it is irrelevant how many years of Catholic schooling one has and I use my number of years only to show from whence I come in terms of what I have been taught. No one should feel in the least embarrassed about their education in the Faith nor should anyone take pride in it. I recall last Sunday’s Gospel reading where the humble publican went home justified whereas the other did not. God bless you all.

Leave a Reply