An Important 22 April Conference in Rome Will Discuss the Confusion Stemming from Amoris Laetitia

An Important 22 April Conference in Rome Will Discuss the Confusion Stemming from Amoris Laetitia

Maike Hickson April 1, 2017

An important Conference has been announced today by the Italian website La Nuova Bussola Quotidiana. On 22 April, there will be an international group of theologians and other Catholic specialists coming together in Rome — at the Columbus Hotel — in order to discuss publicly once more the troubling and confusing parts that are to be found in the Apostolic Exhortation Amoris Laetitia, especially in its chapter 8. The Italian publications La Nuova Bussola Quotidiana and Il Timone are hosting this event which seems to be meant to be a form of public fraternal correction. It is to be lauded because it gives Pope Francis a charitable occasion to make a correction of the scandalous path that he himself has entered, namely: to admit some of the “remarried” and divorced couples to the Sacraments. So far, we have abundant evidence that Pope Francis encourages such a path. The latest proofs of this papal attitude are Cardinal Reinhard Marx’ own testimony that Pope Franicis rejoiced over the liberalizing German pastoral guidelines permitting access to the Sacraments for some of the “remarried” divorcees, as well as the fact that Pope Francis has now chosen Professor Marie-Anne Pelletier — an ardent defender of the “remarried” divorcees — as the author of this year’s Via Crucis Meditations on Good Friday in Rome.

In the following text, we present the translation of an article which was published today by La Nuova Bussola Quotidiana. We wonder whether or not some of the Four Dubia Cardinals themselves will be present in attendance at that meeting, even if they do not appear on the conference schedule itself.

Translation courtesy of Mr. Andrew Guernsey

Witnesses From All Over the World With One Request: “Bring Clarity” Immediately on Amoris Laetitia

Riccardo Cascioli
April 1, 2017

On Saturday, April 22, 2017, in Rome at the Hotel Columbus in Via Della Conciliazione, an international conference will be held, organized by La Nuova Bussola Quotidiana and the monthly magazine Il Timone, entitled “Bringing Clarity One Year after Amoris Laetitia”. Why this title? It has been almost a year since the publication of the Post Synodal Exhortation Amoris Laetitia, a definitely very rich and vast document. But the focus has been primarily on Chapter 8, or rather the one [part] devoted to irregular situations, with particular emphasis on Communion for the divorced and remarried. It is clear that the interpretations in this year have been very different and even diametrically opposed, given also the objective ambiguity of the language used in this chapter. On the one hand, there are those who interpret the text in continuity with the previous magisterium: with utmost attention and care for divorced and remarried persons, but with the impossibility of receiving the Sacrament of Communion for those who live in an objective situation of adultery. On the other hand, there are, instead, those who think that one can receive Communion anyway under certain not well defined conditions and after a not well specified penitential journey. Therefore, there is a situation of evident confusion and disorientation, a completely new situation in the Catholic Church. This is why four cardinals have raised questions so that the Pope might make a clarifying intervention. It is a traditional procedure, called Dubia, in this case there are five questions to which the Pope ought to answer with a ‘yes’ or with a ‘no’. Questions that do not concern only Communion for the divorced and remarried, but concern the whole concept of Catholic morality. Because we must not forget that the stakes are very high and involve three Sacraments: Penance, the Eucharist and Matrimony. We are therefore touching upon the foundations of the Catholic Church. What happened? The Pope did not answer, so the Dubia were made public to facilitate the debate. And debate there was, even insults and threats to the cardinals of Dubia were not lacking, but the Pope’s answer has still not yet arrived. We believe an answer is more necessary and urgent than ever, and it is not just a few elderly cardinals demanding it, as some would have you believe, but rather it is a widespread need in the Church around the world.

Get AQ Email Updates

2 comments on “An Important 22 April Conference in Rome Will Discuss the Confusion Stemming from Amoris Laetitia

  1. ” this event which seems to be meant to be a form of public fraternal correction.”
    I hope no one else thinks anything good will come from this.
    C’mon, Maike, all you have to do is go to the web sites of Nuovo Bussola and Il Timone, and look at their About Us pages, or poke around just a little bit to find out who is behind this.
    Here are a few leads:

  2. Another example of why I castigate myself for even bothering to read what is going on in the Church – anywhere! – anymore. And, from ANYONE’S “point of view.”

    Even Aristotle would have gotten up and walked out of this madhouse, long ago.

    “Did Francis, in fact, write or say X?”

    “Is that statement confirmed by irrefutable evidence?”

    “Does it comport with infallible dogma, or not?”

    End of discussion.

    EVERYTHING above or beyond that is superfluous.

    If anyone comes across PROOF that the Curia or any other body decided to take constructive action, send me a message. I’ll read it with interest.

    Until such time, I am abstaining from the “yet one more extra-super-important conference” movement, none of which have not, since they cannot, produced any Catholic remedy whatsoever.

Leave a Reply